i mentioned putting into the appropriate thread because i have been putting all my sightings in this thread for the last 14 months,but you are quiet right ian it is all one area & it does not have to have its own thread it can easily be put into the salford quays thread as many others have done so in the past. sorry for this causing a little debate,lets hope we can get back down to some serious bird sightings.
It's a tricky one ! I consider my local patch to be the whole of the Salford Docklands, this is the area from Weaste ETW along the Manchester Ship Canal, to Ontario Basin, Trafford Wharf, Media City, Broadway area, Trafford Road Bridge & Pomona area up to the Halfpenny Bridge
As the whole area is now known as Salford Quays I'm personally ok with Pomona sightings going in the Salford Quays sightings, perhaps also sightings from Weaste ETW should also go in Salford Quays, as this site is also a big part of the Quays birding experience, & this would make it more convenient for birders to plan trips to the area
PS I'm currently getting the area's official list together & (when I have the time) I'll also have a go at doing a map for Salford Quays to go on the manchesterbirding site
__________________
Mancunian Birder https://mancunianbirder.wordpress.com Visit my YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCtWoAs4geYL9An0l6w_XgIg
The fact that Pomona is actually seperate from the Quays and is a site in its own right is a worthy reason to keep its own thread (which indeed it is and will, as I was merely asking for opinion as others had asked if it was necessary), but that it lies in another borough has little reasoning for its own thread to me? Very important distinction? On a bird sightings forum- why?
As for me being the only one to post Pomona sightings on the Quays thread, take another read of the thread Nick
I'd say leave it to its own devices as a separate thread, I'd often jump off the Met and scout it and get back on onwards, missing the Quays out. It's an important little place worthy of its own thread an capable of producing the goods. Plus it's a separate borough, as Nick pointed out.
">Does Pomona actually need it's own thread? As part if the Salford Quays it may well be easier to include it within that thread, especially as birds and birding at Pomona often includes elsewhere on the quays"
Salford Quays is in Salford, Pomona is in Trafford; very important distinction !!!
and you're the only one that posts Pomona sightings on the SQ thread !!
(either way, not fussed, James and Steven are the main watchers, their shout ??)
Does Pomona actually need it's own thread? As part if the Salford Quays it may well be easier to include it within that thread, especially as birds and birding at Pomona often includes elsewhere on the quays
1 whinchat (male, first for the year) first found by james walsh,thanks for the text james a lovely looking bird,even managed a few pics. 1 whitethroat (first for the year) possibly 2,male was chased out off the bramble and stood out in view before disappearing with the other bird which i did not manage to get a good look at. 6 wheatears 4m 2f 2 willow warblers (heard only) 1 blackcap male 1 goosander male 2 swallows 14 sand martins 1 skylark 6 lapwings 4 l b b gulls 12 b h gulls 1 mute swan 3 cormorants 6 mallards 2 canada goose with 4 young 2 mistle thrushes 1 song thrush 3 blackbirds 1 grey heron 2 crows 14 magpies 26 woodpigeons 5 starlings 1 robin 8 greenfinches
went for nosey after work to see what destruction was going on and yes there on skylark territory 2 large holes so far,how many more to come
5.30-6.15pm ( binoculars ) still managed
1 common snipe (my first for here) so maybe the diggers have helped in some way. 24 sand martins 2 lapwings 1 skylark, on a different territory. 4 l b b gulls 19 b h gulls 3 cormorants 1 grey heron 7 mallards 4 canada goose 8 magpies 2 goldfinches 3 blackbirds
info thanks to phil kelly. i did manage to join phil around 7.15pm to see the wheatears, that i have been trying to find on there,so well done for finding them phil
3 sand martins, first for the year still around when i left. 1 tufted duck (male) 3 goosanders (2m 1f) 3 l b b gulls 17 b h gulls hundreds more gulls over 1 kestrel 1 collared dove 1 fieldfare 6 cormorants 19 mallards 1 moorhen 6 mute swans 3 canada goose 1 greenfinch 8 goldfinch 1 great tit 1 wren 2 blackbirds 1 grey heron 1 grey wagtail 18 woodpigeons 2 crows 11 magpies
lots off b h gulls (over) no signs off the med gulls. 6 l b b gulls 5 cormorants 5 canada goose 1 goosander (m) 1 little grebe 1 sparrowhawk 1 kestrel 2 mistle thrushes 13 mallards 15 woodpigeons 4 crows 6 magpies 1 blackbird 1 robin 3 blue tits 2 great tits 8 greenfinches
100+ b h gulls 23 common gulls 2 l b b gulls hunreds more over going to roost. 5 cormorants 7 mute swans 4 mallards 1 moorhen 6 lapwings 1 kestrel 5 meadow pipits 6 crows 10 magpies 6 wood pigeons 1 fieldfare, in trees next to adamson house and looked settled. 2 mistle thrushes 2 blue tits 2 great tits 7 blackbirds 1 robin 1 wren 4 greenfinches
12.30 Bitter, bitter winds so didn't stay for long.
Loads of black headed gull with at least 1 common gull Male kestrel hunting Single grey wagtail 2 comerant 3 mistle thrush and an unidentified smaller thrush Great tit heard
3.30-4pm not a single gull perched,all in flight. nice surprise was 4 linnets flying around & then landing in trees next to canal near to cornbrook tram stop. 2 song thrushes (singing) 1 meadow pipit 1 lapwing 1 kestrel 3 cormorants 2 mute swans 1 moorhen 1 blackbird 1 dunnock 1 wren 6 magpies 2 crows 2 collared doves
3.00-4.15pm 50+ b h gulls 2 l b b gulls 4 cormorants 4 mute swans 14 mallards 1 little grebe 1 moorhen 1 lapwing 2 goosanders (over heading towards the quays) 1 grey heron 1 stock dove 4 crows 2 magpies 1 sparrowhawk 2 kestrels
3-5pm 100+ b h gulls 6 common gulls 3 l b b gulls 13 lapwings 3 cormorants 19 mallards 10 canada geese 5 grey herons 4 pied wagtails, also from 4.15pm had a continuous passing off pied wags heading towards the city centre. 5 meadow pipits 1 kestrel 10 mistle thrushes 4 goldfinches 3 greenfinches 2 collared doves 8 magpies 4 crows 5 blackbirds 3 robins 3 wrens 2 dunnocks 1 great tit